Call or text 612-808-6767Get Cash Offer
Blog

Too Many Home Sellers. Not Enough Home Buyers.

Roberto Rodriguez·Chief Legal Officer·
Too Many Home Sellers. Not Enough Home Buyers.

The short answer: sellers now outnumber buyers nationwide by the widest margin on record, but Minnesota is shifting more slowly than the most oversupplied Sun Belt markets. In September 2026, Redfin counted about 1.51 million U.S. home sellers for roughly 929,000 buyers, a 62.6% gap. In Minnesota, inventory rose 12.9% from a year earlier to a seven-year high and pending sales fell 11.5%, yet the Twin Cities median price still rose 1.3% to $395,000. Homes are taking longer to sell and buyers have more room to negotiate, so realistic pricing, and an honest look at whether repairs are worth making before a sale, matter more than they did a year ago.

For years, homeowners were told that a shortage of available houses would keep sellers in control. Buyers competed for limited inventory, homes attracted multiple offers, and properties often sold before their owners had time to reconsider the asking price. That balance is changing across much of the country.

In September 2026, the United States had an estimated 1.51 million home sellers competing for approximately 929,000 buyers, according to Redfin's October 14 housing market report. That means sellers outnumbered buyers by 62.6%, the widest gap in the company's records dating back to 2013. Just a month earlier, the difference was 56.9%.

For homeowners considering a sale, the numbers raise an uncomfortable question: What happens when more people want to sell their homes than there are buyers ready to purchase them?

The answer depends heavily on location. While some Sun Belt markets are experiencing significant oversupply, the Minnesota housing market tells a more complicated story. Homes are taking longer to sell, buyers have more choices, and pricing has become increasingly important. Yet property values in the Twin Cities have remained relatively resilient, suggesting a market that is adjusting rather than collapsing.

America's Housing Market Is Shifting Toward Buyers

The growing imbalance between home sellers and buyers is one of the clearest signs that the housing market has entered a different phase.

Redfin estimates that the number of active buyers nationwide fell to its lowest level since the company began tracking the measure in 2013. Meanwhile, the number of sellers reached its highest point since March 2020. Of the 50 largest metropolitan areas included in its analysis, 41 qualified as buyer's markets in September.

Some of the sharpest differences appeared in the South. In Miami, sellers outnumbered buyers by nearly 159%, while markets such as Nashville and Houston also had substantially more homes available than interested buyers. Years of construction activity, combined with affordability pressures and slower demand, have contributed to those regional imbalances.

But a buyer's market does not necessarily mean falling home prices everywhere. According to Redfin's October 20 Home Price Index report, U.S. home prices increased 0.25% from August to September on a seasonally adjusted basis and were 3.8% higher than a year earlier.

That apparent contradiction is important. There can be more sellers than buyers while prices continue to rise in certain markets. Some homeowners choose not to sell rather than accept lower offers. Others have substantial equity and can afford to wait. Meanwhile, well-maintained properties in desirable neighborhoods can still attract serious competition.

The more immediate change is negotiating power. During the four weeks ending September 20, approximately 21.1% of U.S. home sellers with active listings reduced their asking prices, according to Redfin. That was the highest share for that time of year in the company's records dating back to 2022.

The familiar strategy of listing high and waiting for buyers to compete is becoming less dependable.

What the Latest Numbers Reveal About Minnesota and Minneapolis

Minnesota has not experienced the same degree of oversupply seen in parts of Florida and Texas. Nevertheless, the state's September 2026 housing data points to a market where buyers are gradually gaining leverage.

According to the September 2026 Housing Market Report from Minnesota Realtors, the number of homes available for sale statewide increased 12.9% from a year earlier, reaching 21,090 properties. That represented roughly 2,400 additional homes and the highest inventory level in seven years.

At the same time, pending sales fell 11.5% statewide and 11.7% in the Twin Cities metropolitan area compared with September 2025. Closed sales declined 1.2% across Minnesota and 3.1% in the metro, even as new listings continued to increase.

The result is a housing market with more choices but fewer buyers moving quickly toward closing.

Minnesota's statewide median sale price slipped 0.7% year over year to $354,900 in September. In the Twin Cities, however, the median price increased 1.3% to $395,000. Metro inventory grew 11.2%, reaching 12,411 homes, while the available supply increased to 3.2 months.

That is still below the five to six months generally associated with a balanced housing market. In other words, rising inventory does not automatically mean Minnesota has become an extreme buyer's market.

The change is more visible in the time required to sell a home. Across the Twin Cities, properties took 48 cumulative days on the market, compared with 44 days a year earlier. Sellers there received 97.7% of their original asking price, down from 98.4% the previous September.

Aarica Coleman, President of Minneapolis Area REALTORS®, emphasized the importance of realistic pricing in the association's September report. Although Twin Cities prices have held up, longer selling times are giving buyers more opportunity to evaluate properties and negotiate.

Minneapolis itself continues to show meaningful demand. Redfin's Minneapolis market data for the three months ending in September 2026 reported a median sale price of approximately $369,824, up 4.2% from the previous year, with homes spending a median of 25 days on the market.

The distinction matters. A homeowner selling in Minneapolis, Bloomington, Richfield, or another Twin Cities community should not assume that national headlines describe their neighborhood precisely. Price range, condition, location, and property type can all influence how quickly a home attracts an offer.

Why Selling a Home May Require a Different Strategy in 2026

For sellers, the challenge is no longer simply getting a property onto the market. It is making that property worth choosing when buyers have more alternatives.

During the unusually competitive housing market of recent years, some buyers were willing to overlook outdated kitchens, aging roofs, unfinished repairs, or inconvenient layouts. When available inventory was limited, waiting for a better property could mean losing the opportunity to buy altogether.

Today, buyers in many markets have more time to consider those issues. Higher borrowing costs also make unexpected repairs more difficult to absorb. A house that needs $20,000 or $30,000 in improvements may still attract interest, but buyers are more likely to account for that work when deciding what they can afford.

This creates a difficult calculation for homeowners preparing to sell. Should they spend money renovating before listing? Reduce the asking price to reflect the property's condition? Or consider selling without making repairs?

There is no universal answer.

For a well-maintained home in a desirable neighborhood, a traditional listing may still produce an excellent outcome. For a property with substantial deferred maintenance, however, repairs, staging, carrying costs, and a longer selling period can change the financial picture considerably.

Homeowners researching the best way to sell your house should compare more than the potential sale price. The relevant question is how much they may receive after repairs, commissions, holding costs, concessions, and other transaction expenses.

For someone who needs to relocate, manage an inherited property, or move forward without a lengthy renovation, the ability to sell a house as-is for cash may offer a practical alternative.

This is where companies such as Homestead Road fit into the broader housing market. As a Minnesota-based home-buying company with experience purchasing and renovating older properties, Homestead Road provides homeowners with an alternative to preparing a property for a traditional listing.

A direct cash sale generally involves a different pricing structure from a fully marketed retail sale. The offer needs to account for the home's condition, anticipated renovation expenses, and the buyer's risk. It may therefore be lower than the price a fully repaired property could achieve on the open market. For some homeowners, that difference is worth the reduced work, uncertainty, and time commitment. For others, listing remains the better financial choice.

The important distinction is understanding the trade-off before making a decision.

What Home Sellers Should Expect as 2026 Comes to a Close

The September figures suggest that sellers may need to adjust their expectations, but they do not establish that a major housing downturn is inevitable.

Much depends on mortgage rates, employment conditions, consumer confidence, and the number of homeowners who decide to list their properties. If affordability improves, some buyers who have delayed purchasing may return. If borrowing costs remain elevated, homes that are overpriced or need substantial work could continue to face longer selling periods.

For Minnesota homeowners, local market conditions remain the best starting point. Inventory has increased, and buyers are becoming more selective, but prices across the Twin Cities have shown greater stability than in many of the country's most oversupplied markets.

A seller who can comfortably wait, invest in necessary improvements, and price a home competitively may still find strong demand. Someone facing repairs, an upcoming move, or the costs of maintaining a vacant property may place greater value on a predictable transaction.

At Homestead Road, the belief is that homeowners should have options. Whether someone chooses a traditional listing or the cash sale behind so many “sell my house for cash” searches, the right approach should reflect the property's condition, the owner's financial priorities, and the time available to complete the sale.

The national imbalance between sellers and buyers is an important warning, but not a reason for panic. Real estate remains local, and the difference between a successful sale and a frustrating one often comes down to realistic expectations.

For anyone asking, “Should I sell my house fast in Minnesota or wait for a stronger market?”, the most useful question may no longer be how much the home could sell for in a perfect market. It may be what the home can realistically achieve today, and what it will cost to wait.

In a market where buyers have more choices, preparation, flexibility, and an informed decision may matter more than ever.

If You Are Weighing a Sale This Fall

When buyers have more homes to choose from, a house that needs work competes for fewer of them, and every extra month on the market adds carrying costs: mortgage, taxes, insurance, and utilities. Homestead Road has bought homes across Minnesota since 2007, in as-is condition, with no repairs, showings, or agent commissions. Our home sale calculator puts a traditional listing and a cash sale side by side, and you can request a no-obligation cash offer to see a real number for your property.

Sources and Data Notes

Your cash offer is waiting.

Enter your address to see what your home is worth — free and no obligation.

TextGet Cash Offer Call